Seethru Bats? Is Third Man losing his grip?

Donald Bradman  and George Headley have strong claims to be the best batsmen ever to play cricket.  They were born within nine months of each other in August 1908 and May 1909.  They were both self taught.  As was illustrated here yesterday, they shared a similarly unorthodox stance and grip.

The twins: Bradman and Headley, their bat faces 'shut' and the hands at the back of the bat handles

The photograph of Bradman immediately below shows just how far round the back of the handle are his hands.

This shot of Bradman playing a late cut is a good one to look at his grip in action

In his Art of Cricket, Bradman writes, “For my part I refuse to be dogmatic about one’s grip, because I believe various holds can be satisfactory.  So much depends on the batsman’s methods.”

He describes the position of his hands using golfing terms as ‘a slightly shut face’.  It looks slightly more than ‘slightly’ to Third Man.  Headley’s is an even more extreme version.

Headley with bottom hand behind the handle and it looks as if the index finger is pointed down towards the splice

It has always been argued that, by closing the face in this way, pulls and cuts are struck with a slightly downward facing blade which helps to keep the ball down.

It also means that, when driving, the blade cannot continue very far in an open manner.  The motion through the line the of the ball is broken by the wrists reaching the end of their orbit. 

The follow through can only be effected by a rotation at the shoulders.  The ‘right hander’s’ right (bottom) elbow quickly rises above the left and the bat, rather than passing over the left shoulder passes more to the side of the left shoulder as the next photograph of Bradman reveals.

Coaches will search in vain for a high elbow and a 'correct' alighment of the hips and shoulders. This is 1938 but we'll see plenty of shots like these in tomorrow's ICC T20 Cup Final

Even more importantly perhaps, and well illustrated above, the hips open and are aligned from cover to mid-wicket in a very chest-on fashion.   This development of alignment is one of the most notable adaptions in T20 but also, unintentionally, seems to be a natural consequence of these extreme grips.

Finally, as this sequence taken from The Art of Cricket to illustrate the ‘jumping out to drive’ shows, throwing the hands into the shot with the wrists in these positions means that the batsman’s head is not ‘over the ball’ as the coaching manuals urge but behind the bat as it strikes the ball.  It is as if Bradman, in this case, is looking through the back of his bat as he watches the ball strike the blade. (see the middle shot in the sequence below).

Head over the ball? No, it's back and angled, but this enables Bradman to watch the ball through the back of his bat.

Which, remarkably, is exactly how Roger Federa plays the forehand and backhand drives.

Federa watches the ball through his racket strings, head tilted back, shoulders aligned from cover to midwicket

Food for thought?  Will a pre-determined striking grip develop with the bottom hand further round behind the line of the drive?  Changing a grip is a notoriously tricky and dangerous thing but will batsmen of the future have to have developed more than one grip,  following the path trod by the tennis players?

Advertisements

5 Comments

Filed under Light roller

5 responses to “Seethru Bats? Is Third Man losing his grip?

  1. Tom Redfern

    Mate,
    I thoroughly enjoyed this; bit about Bradman’s head is brilliant. But can I add that the head position in this instance is as it is, because his weight leans back. He’s jumped into the shot No? If you jump into the shot, your head position is a little further back, I think.

    • Dear Balance Man,
      You’re right Tom; Bradman is jumping out to drive. Third Man uses an extreme case to help make a point. Indulge him. But it is surprising just how many people play such forcing shots with the head cocked ‘on one side’ and are therefore looking through the bat at the moment of impact. Give it a go this weekend.

      A hundred in sub-51: It helps to see the ball big as well as to feel ‘there’ … though the memory is fading fast. Also, your captain needs to know that it is senseless having you at any position other than opener. Looking forward to your next match report.
      TM
      For those perplexed by part of this correspondence the background can be found here: http://getahundred.com/blog/archives/1656#comments

  2. Pingback: VVS Relaxman « Down At Third Man

  3. Kamal

    Awesome article! I’ve been searching for one about this batting grip for quite sometime. But, won’t this “seethru” view be disadvantageous in countering late swing?

    • Yes Kamal. It is one of the trade-offs that batsmen make. But it sure worked for Bradman and Headley. In T20, where risks can be taken that might get you a bad name in Test cricket, it could be acceptable. Hope you try it!
      Thank you so much for getting in touch.
      Best wishes
      TM

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s